No, variable pay is not mandatory. It is an optional form of sales compensation based on performance, and employers can choose whether to offer it or not.
Everything About Variable Pay
- Sumeet Shah
- Sep 08, 2022
- 4 min read
- Last updated on Jan 03, 2025
What is Variable Pay?
Variable pay, also known as variable compensation or commission, is a performance-based incentive for employees to meet or exceed specific targets. It can include bonuses, monetary rewards, or even company stocks. The organization typically ties the amount of variable pay to an employee's performance, but factors such as company profits, sales figures, and referrals can also influence it. The metrics used to determine variable pay differ from one organization to another, with each company deciding the criteria that best align with its goals and objectives.
How Variable Pay Works
Variable pay is a compensation that depends on sales performance, often linked to achieving specific targets or goals. Unlike fixed salaries, which are predictable, variable pay fluctuates based on individual, team, or company performance. Common examples include bonuses, commissions, and profit-sharing. Variable pay structure motivates employees to excel by rewarding them for reaching set objectives and aligning their interests with the company’s success. However, it’s essential to structure them fairly to avoid creating unhealthy competition or stress among employees.
Formula:
Variable Pay = Base Achievement × Incentive Rate × Achievement Factor
Calculation:
Base Achievement = $50,000
Incentive Rate = 10%
Achievement Factor = 1.2
Variable Pay = 50,000 × 0.10 × 1.2= 50,000 × 0.12 = $6,000
Types of Variable Pay
Businesses can choose the variable compensation plan that best suits their needs. Here are different criteria for administering variable compensation to employees.
Variable Pay as a Commission
Suppose you’re responsible for selling four shoe brands on a floor filled with shoes from different brands. A customer buys five pairs of shoes, two of which were your shoe brands. You receive a percentage of the total sale value for those two pairs as your commission. This is an example of variable pay, where compensation depends on sales. If no one buys your brand, you receive no variable pay.
Variable Pay as a Percentage of Sales
Take the example of the shoe store again. This time, instead of selling just four brands, you are given a flexible role where you are shuffled around the floor based on customer demand, product knowledge, absentees, and more. The system tracks your sales, and after one to three months, it calculates the total sales value you’ve generated. So, here you receive a fixed percentage based on your job stage, total sales, and other factors.
Variable Pay as a Bonus
Let’s say the shoe store you work at is part of a nationwide chain, where you compete with both colleagues and other branches to increase sales. To encourage healthy competition, the company may implement a bonus scheme. So if the total sales done from each one of your employees reaches a certain target, the company can give bonuses to everyone involved.
Different Variable Pay Programs
Organizations considering variable pay should define eligibility criteria for who will receive the incentive. These criteria can include the job category of an employee, their length of service, job classification, and more.
Here are some common variable incentive pay that companies use:
- Annual Incentive Plan: An annual incentive plan is a commission plan that is given to employees for accomplishing specific targets at the end of a certain sales performance cycle.
- Spot Awards: Spot awards are rewards that recognize the contributions of an employee during a project or a task. These are generally accomplished in a short period of time.
- Discretionary Bonus Plan: A discretionary bonus plan has no set formula or is guaranteed to employees. In this plan, the management determines how large the bonus pool can be and how much should be allocated to different employees after a performance period.
- Profit-sharing Plan: In a profit-sharing plan, the employees share their incentives from the organization’s profits. In this scenario, there is a predetermined formula that is used to allocate profits among employees and to distribute the funds that were accumulated under the plan.
- Gain-sharing Plan: In gain-sharing plans, employees share the results of productivity gains among each other as a group.
- Team/Small-group Incentives: These incentive programs focus on the performance achieved by a small group, like a work team. It is helpful when the output from a group is more easily measurable rather than individual efforts.
- Project Bonus: Organizations can work on several projects simultaneously to earn revenue. For completing projects within the stipulated time, the entire department or individuals can be given a form of additional incentive.
- Retention Bonus: Organizations also pay incentives to retain employees in the company. This can happen with the help of incentive payments or rewards outside of the regular salary of the employee.
Factors to Consider for Variable Pay
1. Success Measurement
For a compensation system based on performance-based rewards, it is important to define success clearly for the employees. What targets they need to achieve, how many sales they need to complete, and other metrics must be measured with an equal scale for each employee. There is no room for ambiguity or loosely defined success measurement guidelines.
2. Competitor Analysis
Have a look at what kind of incentive plan they are using and if it can be implemented in your business. It won’t be beneficial for any company if there is a huge difference between salaries and compensation plans. Being on par with the competition also gives an edge when hiring potential employees or retaining existing ones.
3. Regular Update to Employees
Compensation plans can change as per the market demand, condition of the company, available employee strength, and other factors. This change should be updated to the employees on a regular basis so that they are always informed about what they need to do and what their updated target has become.
4. Realistic and Achievable Targets
Targets are there to encourage employees to push themselves. By achieving it, they not only get a chance to be paid extra, but it gives an internal sense of satisfaction as well. This is why it is important that the targets you set for the employees are realistic and achievable. Otherwise, it can have a negative effect on them and seeing that the targets are somewhat unachievable, they end up putting in even less of an effort.
Pros and cons of variable pay
Variable pay is a valuable asset that ties employee rewards to performance, driving motivation and aligning individual efforts with organizational goals. However, like any strategy, it comes with its own set of advantages and challenges.
Pros:
- Encourages better employee performance
- Aligns pay with business goals
- Motivates teamwork and collaboration
- Rewards top-performing employees
Cons:
- May create unhealthy competition
- Difficult to implement fairly
- Unpredictable earnings for employees
- Requires constant performance tracking
Understanding the pros and cons helps organizations implement a plan that motivates employees while maintaining fairness and balance. A well-structured system can turn challenges into opportunities for growth and success.
Challenges in implementing variable pay
Implementing variable pay comes with several challenges. One of the key difficulties is setting realistic and achievable performance targets that motivate employees without causing frustration.
If targets are too ambitious, they may demotivate employees or result in unhealthy competition. Additionally, poor communication of the criteria and transparency in calculating variable pay can lead to misunderstandings and dissatisfaction.
Ensuring fairness across different roles and departments is also critical, as disparities in performance measures can lead to resentment. Finally, the unpredictability of variable pay can make it difficult for employees to manage their finances effectively, impacting morale.
How can Incentivate Help with Variable Pay?
A variable pay commission management system can provide a lot of benefits to enterprises and SMEs alike. For any organization that wants to increase its productivity, improving its performance is a vital requirement. And improving the performance of employees, incentives can work like a charm.
This is where variable pay software like Incentivate comes into the picture. Calculating sales commissions can be a difficult and error-prone process. Incentivate automates the sales commissions calculation so that you can deliver accurate and timely payments to your employees. It also enhances the transparency of your existing salesforce so that you can be aware of their performance in real-time.
Being a no-code sales commission and variable pay management system, it can easily be used by the sales team and other employees without any hassle. With integration with the most commonly used CRMs, ERP software, HRMS, and more, Incentivate gets a 360-degree view of the organization and everyone working in it.
Implementing Incentivate in the organization is pretty straightforward and its innovative design helps in faster implementation. The best part of this is that it can seamlessly scale as per the company and covers every role in an organization. It ensures that your data remains secure by following international guidelines and requirements for security and compliance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Variable Pay mandatory?
What is the most common variable pay for performance?
The most common variable pay for performance includes commissions, bonuses, and profit-sharing, typically tied to individual or team achievements.
Why do employers use Variable Pay?
Employers use variable pay to motivate employees, align compensation with sales performance, attract top talent, and drive business results by rewarding attainments.